• News
  • FAKE ALERT: Rana Ayyub, Abhisar Sharma, JNUSU label lockdown violators as ‘migrant labourers’
This story is from March 31, 2020

FAKE ALERT: Rana Ayyub, Abhisar Sharma, JNUSU label lockdown violators as ‘migrant labourers’

Journalist Rana Ayyub shared a photo of a group of men being made to squat and hold ears by police officials and labelled it as punishment meted out to “Labourers leaving the lockdown”.
FAKE ALERT: Rana Ayyub, Abhisar Sharma, JNUSU label lockdown violators as ‘migrant labourers’
Key Highlights
  • Journalist Rana Ayyub shared a photo of a group of men being made to squat and hold ears by police officials and labelled it as punishment meted out to “Labourers leaving the lockdown”.
  • JNUSU, the official Twitter account of the JNU students' union, shared the same photo with a similar caption.
  • The people being made to squat were coronavirus lockdown violators.
CLAIM
Journalist Rana Ayyub shared a photo of a group of men being made to squat and hold ears by police officials and labelled it as punishment meted out to “Labourers leaving the lockdown”.
“Punishing the labourers for leaving the lockdown. Cry my beloved country,” she had tweeted.
Here’s the screengrab of the now deleted tweet by Ayyub:
rana ayyub

The content of the tweet was picked up by several Twitter users, who posted the photo making similar claims.


Journalist Abhisar Sharma too shared the photo with a similar claim in a video posted on March 30, 2020 by YouTube account NewsClickin.
One can see the visual at 12:31.

Lockdown में प्लानिंग की कमी पर सवाल पूछा जायेगा


JNUSU, the official Twitter account of the JNU students' union, shared the same photo with a similar caption.

JNUSU labelled the police officials as “Shameless men in uniform who 'punished' jobless migrants trying to go home”.

TRUTH
The people being made to squat were coronavirus lockdown violators, who were shamed by cops for defying guidelines.
VERIFICATION AND METHODOLOGY
Using reverse-image search on Google, we found the original photo used in an article by ABP news on March 25, 2020.
Titled ‘IN PICS: Cops Shame Those Violating Lockdown By Making Them Do Sit-Ups And Hold Ears’, the article carried pictures of how police officers punished lockdown offenders.
The original photo was taken on March 24, 2020 and is credited to news agency PTI.
The caption given to the photo read -- “Kanpur: Police personnel punish offenders flouting lockdown guidelines, imposed in wake of coronavirus pandemic, at Chakeri area of Kanpur, Tuesday.”
Original image

VERDICT
Times Fact Check has found the photo of men punished for violating lockdown rules has been shared with misleading claims of them being poor migrant labourers punished for going home.
End of Article
FOLLOW US ON SOCIAL MEDIA